Best Whiskey For Old Fashion

Prepare The Old Fashioned

Ultimate Whiskey Old Fashioned || Whiskey Mixed Drinks at Home
  • Add 1 oz of whisky . You can play around with this to figure out what you like best

  • Add 1 ounce of your orange simple syrup

  • Add one orange slice and muddle

  • Add one more ounce of whisky. Remember 2 to 1 ratio

  • Stir and let it sit for 2 minutes

  • And Bob’s your uncle, you have just made an Old Fashioned, Whisky Boss style.


    Basil Haydens Kentucky Straight Bourbon

    Basil Haydens is a stand alone bourbon, enjoy it neat, on the rocks, or triumphantly in an Old Fashioned. Its a bourbon sparked with rye, so yes, its spicy. But the rich aromatic notes of honey, peppermint, and citrus envelope the senses, welcoming your taste buds like an old companion.

    Rarely does such a unique combination of quality and craft manifest itself in a way youre left wondering why havent I experienced this before? Basil Haydens is a single small batch bourbon patiently aged and bottled at 80 proof. However, dont mistake its proof as a sign of a mild temperament. No, this bourbon is bold and savory.

    At first sip, youll be curious who was asleep at the wheel when it was priced. Few, other rye-laced bourbons can compare to Basil Haydens quality at this price point. So, if youre looking for an amazing addition to your Old Fashioned recipe, this is a must-try spirit. Really, whats stopping you?

    How much does Basil Haydens Kentucky Bourbon cost?

    Basil Haydens Kentucky Straight Bourbon costs around $45 per bottle.

    Middle West Dark Pumpernickel Rye

    Middle West

    “The best whiskey for an Old Fashioned is a higher proof rye whiskey, preferably above 45% ABV,” says whiskey expert Christopher Sebastian of Blind Barrels. He goes on to recommend Middle West Dark Pumpernickel Rye, telling us that “Middle West Dark Pumpernickel Rye is a phenomenal choice at 48% ABV, it holds up well to being stirred with ice, and the flavor notes of brown sugar, vanilla, cinnamon, and molasses provide an amazing balance to the sugar and bitters of the cocktail.”

    Don’t Miss: Vodka And Blue Curacao Drinks

    The History Of Old Fashioned Whiskey

    An Old Fashioned is a classic whiskey cocktail, made with bitters and a simple orange garnish. The drink consists of whiskey, bitters, club soda or seltzer, simple syrup and an orange twist for garnish. It& rsquor s traditionally served over ice in a tumbler glass. Its roots trace back to the 1800s when it was considered a morning pick-me-up. Nowadays it is often served as an after-dinner drink. The Old Fashioned is easy enough to make at home but can also be ordered from almost any bar or restaurant that serves cocktails.

    Is Rye Or Bourbon Better For An Old Fashioned

    The 4 Best Bourbon Whiskeys for an Old Fashioned

    When it comes to what whiskey to use for an old fashioned, it will depend on your personal preference.

    Rye and bourbon have distinct tastes and flavor profiles an old fashioned with bourbon will taste much different than an old fashioned with rye whiskey.

    Rye mash consists of rye, while bourbon mash consists of corn. Rye will have a more spicy and dry taste, while corn will have a sweeter and full-bodied taste.

    Typically, rye whiskies are much more intense than bourbon whiskies. Many bourbons will be sweet and will typically have hints of vanilla.

    If you are in the mood for a more peppery, bolder old fashioned, use rye whiskey. If you are looking for a lighter-bodied drink that is sweet, use bourbon.

    The best rye whiskey for old fashioned will be Woodford Reserve Rye Whiskey . Buffalo Trace Bourbon is the best bourbon for an old fashioned .

    Read Also: Easy Drinks To Make With Rum

    Copper And Kings Old Fashioned Bitters

    Although the name itself says it works great for old fashioned, these bitters also go well with Manhattan. The company had their specialist craft these old-fashioned bitters. They combine botanical herbs and concentrated oils into a Brandy base with honey and orange peel, which is then barrel-aged to mix with flavor.

    This bitter competes with Regans orange bitters for the best orange bitters for old-fashioned.

    The original website says these bitters blend spices, herbs, botanical extracts, and oils, and are prepared in an alembic brandy base. It is mixed with honey, vapor distilled orange peel and then aged with American Oak. It is 100% natural with no artificial ingredients or preservatives. It contains glycerine and is a beautiful caramel color.

    Perfect This Classic Cocktail With These Ready

    Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the bestproducts youcan learn more about ourreview process here.We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

    The original cocktail, a basic Old Fashioned is not difficult to make. Sugar muddled with bitters, a couple ounces of whiskey, some ice, maybe an orange twist if youre fancyits not rocket science or a Ramos Gin Fizz . But making a really good Old Fashioned is much more complicated. Because there are so few ingredients, each one needs to be just right, and the cocktail needs to be perfectly mixed to just the right dilution. Thats where a ready-made mix comes in handy.

    In my experience, theres less room for error and variability when you have prepped out a great mix, says WithCo Cocktails co-founder Bradley Ryan. The key is to hold the same methodology and flavor in your mix as youd expect from a from scratch drink.

    These bottled Old Fashioned mixes just need ice and whiskey . Theyre consistent and expertly crafted, so youll get the precise Old Fashioned you want every time. Find the best mix for you.

    You May Like: Ace Of Spades Gold Champagne

    Allrecipes Community Tips And Praise

    “My favorite,” says Todd Marsh. “I always use a sugar cube and pour a little bitters and juice from the maraschino cherries jar over it before crushing it along the bottom of the glass.”

    “Amazing drink and my stand-by selection,” according to Laura Turley Francis. “If Don Draper loves them, why can’t you?”

    “Excellent and classic,” raves nannajoanna. “It really makes so much difference when it’s made from scratch. My only substitution: I used rye whiskey instead of bourbon.”

    Editorial contributions by Corey Williams

    How Strong Is The Old

    How I Make an Old Fashioned | the ONE cocktail you must know

    The old-fashioned is definitely a strong drink. With little dilution and no significant mixer, its not much lighter than a straight pour of whiskey. The alcohol content of an old-fashioned made with an 80-proof whiskey falls around 32 percent ABV . Those old-timers would be happy to know that it still has that kick they were looking for.

    Read Also: Vodka Is Made From What

    Also Check: Scatter Brain Peanut Butter Whiskey

    Balvenie Double Wood Scotch 12 Years

    Region: Speyside, Scotland Taste: Apricot, honey, and oak Price: $69

    The history of Balvenie Double Wood Scotch 12 years started in 1993. Back then, the double aging method, performed in two different types of barrels, was more of an experiment. An experiment that also led to the name Double Wood. More than twenty years later, it is apparent that this experiment was highly successful.

    Balvenie first ages their Scotch in ex-Bourbon barrels for 12 years. After that, the spirit ages for an additional nine months in former Oloroso Sherry casks. The result is filtered, colored, and bottled at 40% alcohol. A few percent more would have been nice to emphasize the flavors more, but we will not complain.

    The flavors are mild, with delicate notes of apricot and honey. Then, in the finish, more intense wood notes and dryness. The oak provides a slight tingling sensation on the tongue without making the Whisky give up its mild character. A completely different profile compared to Laphroaig.

    Why we like it: The flavors are balanced well, not too bold, and not too overpowering. -Creating a delicate and easy-to-sip Scotch Old Fashioned.

    Old Fashioned With Bourbon

    Bourbon, among other requirements, uses a mash bill of at least 51 percent corn and is typically sweeter on the palate than rye.

    1. Elijah Craig Small Batch

    • Why We Love It: With hints of caramel and light oak, Elijah Craig is such a well-balanced option for an Old Fashioned. Not too sweet, not too spicy. If you want your cocktail to veer either direction, simply add a touch more simple syrup or bitters , respectively. But we love Elijah because its so even-keeled as the all-important base ingredient, while also remaining affordable and available.

    2. Makers Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon

    • Why We Love It: For the wheat-loving bourbon crowd, Makers Mark, with its notes of vanilla, cinnamon, and bread, is our go-to choice for an Old Fashioned. Want your Old Fashioned more wheaty? Larceny Small Batch is another stellar option at $29.

    3. Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    • Why We Love It: This is the perfect tweener choice for fans of both bourbon and rye Old Fashioneds. Make no mistake, Buffalo Trace is a bourbon, but its suspected mash bill is probably around 10 percent rye. So your Old Fashioned with Buffalo Trace is gonna have hints of toffee, cinnamon, and a little spice .

    Read Also: Substitute For White Cooking Wine

    Don’t Miss: Does Sonic Have Root Beer Floats

    The 8 Best Whiskeys For Old Fashioneds

    When it comes to classic cocktails, not many are more recognized than the Old Fashioned. At its core it is a relatively easy cocktail to make just a few simple ingredients of whiskey, bitters and sugar. From there, you can make it your own. You might add a garnish of orange or cherries, but changing any of the standard ingredients will change the drink.

    What Is The Best Whiskey For An Old Fashioned

    The 4 Best Bourbon Whiskeys for an Old Fashioned

    When it comes to crafting a delicious Old Fashioned, youll want to choose a whiskey that will bring out the nuances of the cocktail. A great choice for an Old Fashioned is Old Hamer Straight Rye. This whiskey has an intense, spicy flavor that pairs well with the sweetness of the simple syrup and bitters in the drink. Another excellent option is Kuiper Belt Aged 8 Years Straight Kentucky Bourbon, which has a robust flavor of leather, tobacco and oak. Additionally, Sipes& rsquor Double Oaked Smoked Barrel Bourbon offers sweet notes of caramel and vanilla that are contrasted by the smokiness of the barrel-aged whiskey. Other great whiskeys for crafting an Old Fashioned include Bare Knuckle Straight Wheat Whiskey, Border Bourbon, Trail& rsquor s End Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, and Four Roses Yellow Label.

    Also Check: Long Island Iced Tea Ingredients 1 2 Oz Tequila

    Is Makers Mark Suitable For An Old Fashioned Cocktail

    Yes, Maker& rsquor s Mark is an excellent choice for making an Old Fashioned cocktail. It has a unique flavor profile that is both sweet and strong, with touches of citrus. The whiskey has a smooth finish that pairs especially well with the bitters typically used in an Old Fashioned, creating a classic cocktail with a rich and complex flavor. Additionally, Maker& rsquor s Mark is relatively low in alcohol content compared to other whiskeys, making it perfect for sipping or mixing into other drinks.

    Wild Turkey Rare Breed

    Nicholas Bennett, beverage director at Porchlight in New York City

    ABV: 54.1%

    Average Price:$45

    Why This Bourbon?

    I really like Wild Turkey Rare Breed. I want a high proof spirit with a high-rye mash bill when I am using a bourbon for my old fashioned and Wild Turkey uses the same high-rye mash bill for all its products. I guess because of the low proof for a barrel-proof bourbon, or possibly because the packaging just doesnt scream pick me up!, this bottle doesnt seem to get the attention it deserves.

    Read Also: What To Mix With Scotch

    High West Whiskey Double Rye

    The High West Whiskey Double Rye is made in Kentucky and costs only 28$. Its a combination of two types of Straight Rye Whiskey, one aged for two years and the other for nine years.

    The tasting notes of this whiskey include honeysuckle, oak, and vanilla, so its mild but still suitable for making cocktails.

    Overall, its not very strong but has good spice notes, so if youre looking for a spicy whiskey for your Old-Fashioned, look no further than this one.

    Remember that sipped neat, the taste of this whiskey is slightly muted.

    It almost tastes diluted, and you only get light notes of oak and vanilla and the slight sweetness from honeysuckle and honey.

    However, if you add this whiskey to your Old-Fashioned, you will get a great cocktail because the other ingredients will balance out the spiciness and pronounce the light notes and sweetness.

    In a nutshell, this whiskey makes a great choice for spicy cocktails.

    Best Canned Rtd Old Fashioned: Dashfire

    Old Fashioned Cocktail

    Courtesy of Total Wine

    Heading out on a camping trip? Stock up on a few cans of this ready-to-drink Old Fashioned to sip around the bonfire. And we do mean sip. With its woodsy, piney notes and spice-laden flavor, it packs some heat and should be savored. Its as delicious as it is portable, made with four different bitters, bourbon, and natural sugar cane juice.

    While you can, of course, pour it into a glass over ice with a cherry and an orange twist, its also perfectly acceptable to drink straight from the can. So, keep some in the fridge and upgrade your next al fresco happy hour.

    You May Like: What Wine Goes With Indian Food

    The Best Bourbon For An Old Fashioned

    Bourbon whiskey is a good choice for an Old Fashioned because of its sweet flavor. The sweetness helps to offset the bitterness brought on by the bitters, while also complementing the citrus notes, creating a well-balanced drink.

    Additionally, bourbon whiskey tends to have a higher proof than other types of whiskey, which means that it will retain its flavor even when diluted with water or ice.

    With these factors in mind, some of the best whiskeys to use in an old fashion include Bulleit Bourbon, Knob Creek Bourbon, and Makers Mark Bourbon.

    Bulleit Bourbon is a high-quality whiskey inspired by the whiskey pioneered over 150 years ago.

    The uniqueness of Bulleit Bourbon comes from its blend of rye, corn, and barley malt, which gives it a bold and spicy character. In addition, the Kentucky limestone-filtered water provides the bourbon with a light and refreshing taste.

    Bulleit Bourbon earned a gold medal at the 2021 San Francisco World Spirits Competition, proving that it is a top-quality whiskey. If youre looking for a unique and well-crafted old-fashioned look no further than Bulleit.

    Knob Creek 9-Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey is widely considered to be a benchmark in the bourbon category. This premium whiskey is made from a mash of corn, rye, and barley, and is aged in white oak barrels for nine years.

    The 9-year is bottled at 100 proof, which provides a bolder flavor than many other bourbons on the market.

    You May Like: Alcohol Content Of Coors Beer

    How To Make An Old Fashioned Cocktail

    An Old Fashioned is a very popular whiskey cocktail. It is a cocktail that could be made from a spicy rye whiskey as well, but today bourbon is preferred. Keep in mind that the bourbon that you choose can drastically change the flavor profile your Old Fashioned has.

    In my list of the best bourbons for an Old Fashioned, I add some tasting note comments for you to help you pick the bourbon that best feeds your personal preference.

    There are a few different recipes out there for an Old Fashioned. Some use lemons or oranges instead of cherry as the garnish. Some use simple syrup instead of raw sugar. They all use bitters, but some use flavored bitters.

    This is the basic Old Fashioned recipe that I use. It is classic and it is a good place to start. It will also help you to identify if you are looking for something else.

    Read Also: G.h. Mumm Champagne Brut

    Also Check: Wine Country Gift Baskets Coupon Code

    Willett Family Estate Bottled Rye 4 Year

    Average Price: $70.80

    Alcohol Content: 55%

    Why Its Best For Old Fashioned:

    Willett Family Estate Bottled Rye 4 Year is a single barrel offering whiskey with a heavy dose of pepper and citrus.

    Bourbon is a bit sweeter than rye whiskey, so if you want a mixed drink with a kick of spiciness, Willet Family Estate can be a good option.

    Having Fun With The Ice

    Best Whiskies to Mix a Bourbon Old Fashioned

    Since weve gotten into making Old Fashioned cocktails at home, Adam dorked out a little and looked into the how and why of clear, large ice cubes. None of this is required for your cocktail, but since we used two of his ice balls in our photo and considering weve already bonded over our love of the Old Fashioned, I thought Id take a shot at explaining what weve learned.

    Im sure youve seen various large ice cube molds like this sphere mold . The problem is that if you just add water and freeze, you will be left with cloudy ice. Worse still, if you use the sphere mold, the water freezes in such a way that when you add the sphere to your drink, it has a very high chance of breaking into pieces.

    This all matters because cloudier ice cubes are less dense so they melt much quicker and break apart easier than clearer ice cubes. In other words, the clearer ice cubes are, the less dilution your cocktail will need to endure. And bonus, clear ice looks cooler.

    So how do you make clear ice cubes? There are quite a few gadgets you can buy online. We went the more DIY, budget-friendly route. After some research, we found this tutorial for making clear ice balls using an insulated mug.

    We use our tap water since we have found it freeze quite clear using this method. The tap water in the last home we had did not produce clear cubes so we found that it was best to use filtered or boiled water.

    Here are the steps for doing it :

  • Fill the mold with water.
  • You May Like: Old Camp Peach Pecan Whiskey


    Related articles